Connect with us

BASKETBALL

Elon Musk’s pay package from Tesla, worth more than $50 billion, cannot be reinstated, a Delaware judge ordered. The judge said she would not reverse her decision to strike down the enormous compensation package, which helped make Musk the richest person in the world. Read more:

Published

on

A Delaware judge on Monday affirmed an earlier ruling that rescinded a giant pay package that Tesla had awarded its chief executive, Elon Musk.

The pay, in the form of stock options, was worth more than $50 billion and helped make Mr. Musk the richest person in the world. The package is now worth $100 billion after Tesla’s share price jumped sharply in recent weeks.

The judge, Chancellor Kathaleen St. J. McCormick of the Delaware Court of Chancery, struck down the award in January, ruling that shareholders had not been properly informed of its details and that members of Tesla’s board were not sufficiently independent.

The pay comes from a 2018 award that said Mr. Musk would get all the options only if Tesla’s stock price soared and its sales and earnings grew strongly. Few expected Mr. Musk to achieve all of those targets because Tesla was still struggling to sell enough electric cars to become profitable. But Tesla’s business took off and its stock rocketed higher, allowing Mr. Musk to earn all the options in the following years. He has to hold them for five years.

The shareholder who brought the suit, Richard J. Tornetta, contended that Tesla’s board had not acted independently of Mr. Musk when devising the package and that the company had provided “materially misleading” information to investors. In her January ruling, after a trial in 2022, Chancellor McCormick said, “The process leading to the approval of Musk’s compensation plan was deeply flawed.”

To try to get the judge to change her mind, Tesla’s lawyers argued that shareholders were sufficiently informed when they overwhelmingly voted again for the package in June. But in her ruling on Monday, Chancellor McCormick wrote that the Tesla lawyers’ arguments had several flaws. Among them was that they could not hope to flip a decision “based on evidence they created after trial.”

She also said a “stockholder vote standing alone cannot ratify a conflicted-controller transaction,” referring to a situation in which a major shareholder has influence over a board and its decisions.

In any case, Chancellor McCormick said, the June vote was flawed because the board presented “materially misleading” information to shareholders in the proxy statement urging them to ratify Mr. Musk’s pay package again.
Among the “many ways in which the proxy statement mangles the truth,” she wrote, was the assurance that a new vote would change the outcome of the case.

headshot
Behind the Journalism
Our business coverage. Times journalists are not allowed to have any direct financial stake in companies they cover.
Here’s more on our standards and practices.
Tesla said on X, the social media site that Mr. Musk owns, that it would appeal the decision.

“A Delaware judge just overruled a supermajority of shareholders who own Tesla and who voted twice to pay @elonmusk what he’s worth,” the company said on its corporate account. “This ruling, if not overturned, means that judges and plaintiffs’ lawyers run Delaware.”

Also on X, Mr. Musk reposted comments from supporters and stated, “Shareholders should control company votes, not judges.”

Tesla’s board of directors will most likely try to fashion a new pay package that falls under the jurisdiction of Texas, where the company has since moved its corporate registration from Delaware, said Charles Elson, the founding director of the Weinberg Center for Corporate Governance at the University of Delaware.

But any new compensation award will be vulnerable to legal challenges if the board does not demonstrate more independence from Mr. Musk, Mr. Elson said. “They can always create a new package,” he said. “But they have to be very careful in the way they construct it.”
Mr. Elson praised the decision, saying a ruling in Mr. Musk’s favor “would have really changed for the worse Delaware conflict-of-interest law.”

Chancellor McCormick also ordered Tesla to pay $345 million in fees to lawyers who represented shareholders in the case. That was far less than the $5.6 billion that the lawyers had sought.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

BASKETBALL1 week ago

Serena Williams beat the summer heat while showcasing her toned legs during a family outing on Thursday. The Grand Slam champ, 43, who some fans think is ‘too thin’ after seeing a recent bikini snap, stepped out in a burgundy romper while enjoying a rare public outing with her husband and two children in New York city…see more Adorable photos

BASKETBALL2 weeks ago

“Thrice-Bitten, Still Unbroken” – Serena Vows Revenge Against Naomi Osaka in 2025 US Open Thriller ≥ “S*xism and Th*ft” – Serena’s Scathing Accusations Spark New Rivalry as She Seeks Redemption Against Osaka 👊🔥 ” can Serena Overcome Osaka Jinx and Claim US Open Victory?

BASKETBALL2 weeks ago

King Charles anger infuriated as he uncovers the truth about Archie’s birth story and biological parents…The lies and deceptions Meghan Markle and Prince Harry told to conceal the truth…..Prince William’s outraged and promise to make Meghan pay for her treacherous act…. Read more

BASKETBALL2 weeks ago

American Eagle is standing firm, saying it won’t apologize for its viral Sydney Sweeney ad campaign: “Great jeans look good on everyone.” Read more here

BASKETBALL2 weeks ago

JUST IN: United States President Donald Trump Demands Prosecution of Taylor Swift, Joe Biden, Barack Obama, Kamala Harris, Oprah Winfrey, Al Sharpton, Bruce Springsteen, Stephen Colbert, and Beyoncé in Explosive New Rant

BASKETBALL3 weeks ago

Sad News: Michelle Obama tried to keep Malia and Sasha’s drinking and smoking photos out of spotlight. Read more

BASKETBALL3 weeks ago

Heartbreaking News. Latest Royal Announcement Reveals Princess Charlotte Has Begun Treatment at a Leading UK Hospital — Prince William’s Painful Confession: ‘My Daughter Has a Hereditary Illness… Please Pray for Her Recovery…. See more below 👇

BASKETBALL3 weeks ago

Heart wrenching 💔😢 just a day after the death of WWE star Hulk Hogan…..Willie Hugh Nelson, the beloved American country music singer, guitarist, songwriter, actor, and activist, has passed away peacefully at his home in Spicewood, Texas, at the age of 92.

BASKETBALL3 weeks ago

SHOCKING:”Footage of Jay Z and Diddy “taking turns” on Beyonce at a Diddy party in 2003 are allegedly being sold on the dark web. Videos and pictures are starting to pop up all over the Internet”. SEE VIDEOS & PICS VIA LINK…

BASKETBALL3 weeks ago

Ozzy Osbourne is dead: Black Sabbath singer dies ‘surrounded by love’ aged 76

BASKETBALL3 weeks ago

Taylor’s father Scott had quintuple bypass surgery. Andrea, Taylor and Austin, were with him through the entire surgery and recovery process. Taylor’s rep also told the procedure was NOT the result of a heart attack, and he’s feeling just great We wish Scott health, strength and a speedy recovery.❤️💛

BASKETBALL4 weeks ago

Patrick Mahomes Shares 10 Cute Photos and Videos of New Baby Golden Raye with Wife Brittany and Their Other Two Children, Sterling and Bronze – but Eagle-Eyed Fans Noticed Something Strange About Golden That All Patrick’s Kids Have: “Golden Is Just Too Cute…” See more 👇👇👇

Copyright © 2024 USAgets